Vue normale

Il y a de nouveaux articles disponibles, cliquez pour rafraîchir la page.
À partir d’avant-hierFlux principal

I Visited a Chinese NAS Factory – And Here is What I Saw…

Par : Rob Andrews
7 avril 2025 à 18:00

Visiting a NAS Production Facility in Shenzhen, China – The CWWK Factory and Office Tour

As part of a broader effort to explore the landscape of Chinese tech manufacturers, I recently visited the facilities of CWWK (ChangWang) in Shenzhen, China. CWWK is best known in enthusiast circles for producing NAS motherboards and compact computing solutions, often associated with budget-friendly, DIY network storage builds. My visit aimed to independently assess the scope and structure of their operations. What made this particular tour notable was the access I was granted: no NDAs were signed, there were no editorial restrictions placed on what I could film or ask, and I was permitted to record freely inside their production and R&D spaces.

This is uncommon, particularly in the tech hardware space, where many brands—especially in Asia—are typically guarded about internal processes, even when media are invited. The open format allowed for a more thorough and independent evaluation, without needing to speculate based on secondhand reports or promotional material.

It’s important to contextualize how the visit came about. CWWK did not arrange or sponsor my trip to China in any way. I was in the region for a series of self-funded visits to multiple tech companies, looking to gain a clearer understanding of how various hardware brands operate behind the scenes. The idea was to go beyond spec sheets and product listings and see what real infrastructure, if any, stood behind companies whose products are often marketed under many different brand names on platforms like AliExpress, Amazon, and Alibaba.

I reached out to CWWK on short notice—roughly 10 to 14 days prior—and they agreed to the visit. The fact that they were able to accommodate the tour with minimal lead time is worth noting. It doesn’t rule out the possibility of some presentation enhancements being made in preparation, but it does suggest that the company was not reliant on elaborate staging to present a working production environment.

The first location I visited was a mixed-use building that included administrative offices, logistics personnel, and access to part of the factory floor. Externally, the building bore no clear CWWK branding, which initially raised questions about ownership or exclusivity. Inside, however, the picture was more cohesive: staff wore uniforms bearing CWWK logos, and product runs on the factory floor featured motherboards that matched CWWK’s catalog.

While I wasn’t given lease documentation or corporate records, the volume of CWWK-branded activity suggested the company either occupies a substantial portion of the facility or has secured long-term, semi-exclusive use of the space. Several floors were accessible, and the presence of both production and support teams indicated that this was more than a satellite or temporary operation. Even so, it’s likely this building is part of a larger industrial complex shared with other tenants, which is common practice in Shenzhen’s manufacturing zones.

One of the key questions I brought to the visit concerned product design and IP ownership—specifically, whether CWWK truly engineers its own hardware or rebrands ODM (original design manufacturer) platforms that are available generically to other companies. In a formal meeting with several members of their team, facilitated by a translator, I was told that all motherboard designs are created in-house.

The company emphasized that while many of their designs do appear under other brand names, including through known resellers or system integrators, the core engineering and schematics originate from their internal teams. Some of these designs, they explained, are distributed under license or through contract manufacturing relationships.

While I wasn’t shown the full design pipeline or documentation for each SKU, I was given access to product schematics, test rigs, and development areas. Based on what I observed, it’s reasonable to conclude that CWWK controls the design process and that their platforms are later distributed—often without clear attribution—by partner companies.

Technical support and warranty policies are often ambiguous when it comes to imported tech from overseas sellers, so I took the opportunity to ask about their post-sales procedures. According to CWWK staff, customers who purchase through major e-commerce channels like AliExpress and Alibaba are serviced directly by the company’s internal support team. This contradicts the assumption that resellers handle all inquiries. They described a standard one-year warranty policy, during which defective products are repaired where feasible rather than replaced outright.

While this approach may not satisfy buyers expecting instant replacements, it aligns with broader industry trends aimed at reducing e-waste and extending hardware lifespans. I observed a dedicated support office where staff were responding to issues, many of which involved firmware or BIOS concerns. The responses to my questions were generally clear but did follow a templated structure, which made it difficult to determine how adaptable their support might be in complex cases.

Moving onto the factory floor, I was able to observe multiple stages of the production workflow. The environment combined automated processes—such as SMT (surface mount technology) component placement and soldering—with manual checkpoints, where staff would verify board integrity, inspect connector alignment, and move products between stations. The factory space showed signs of active use: floor scuffing, desk wear, and tooling marks suggested long-term operation rather than short-term setup.

Workers were equipped with anti-static wrist straps, and safety protocols appeared to be in place, though a few inconsistencies were observed. For instance, not all staff were wearing the full lab coats or coverings that I was required to wear as a visitor. While that’s not uncommon in similar facilities, it’s worth noting in the context of manufacturing discipline. Overall, the workflow followed a logical structure, and there were observable quality checks along the line, including one instance where a misaligned port was flagged and redirected for correction.

Direct interaction with factory personnel was limited, mainly due to language barriers and the guided nature of the tour. I attempted brief conversations, but most staff were focused on their tasks and understandably uninterested in lengthy exchanges with a foreign visitor.

I did not observe any signs of distress or visible overwork, but equally, I did not have enough time or context to draw firm conclusions about working conditions. The facility walls displayed motivational signage, some of which featured quite stern phrasing around responsibility and company reputation.

These types of messages—such as “Your mistakes are our mistakes”—may reflect common workplace culture in the region rather than specific managerial attitudes. In contrast, a separate building used for research and marketing featured more aspirational language. These environmental details may offer some insight into the tone and structure of the company, although they should be interpreted cautiously.

A portion of the facility was allocated to repairs and technical diagnostics. I observed several staff members actively responding to customer-reported issues and working on returned products. Desks were equipped with diagnostic tools and some BIOS interfaces were visible on screens.

In a nearby room, technicians were repairing or reworking boards—examples included reseating CPUs, correcting poorly soldered connectors, and inspecting DIMM slots.

Although the scale of this area was not massive (around six to eight desks), it indicated an operational RMA process. I did not assess how quickly repairs are processed or whether every return is examined manually, but the team appeared to be addressing real customer issues, not simply staging activity for the tour. Staff in this area were dressed more casually than the production line workers, likely due to the nature of their tasks involving pre-owned or defective components.

The second facility, located in the Beta Industrial Park, was clearly identified as a CWWK property. Unlike the first building, this one included prominent company branding, product showcases, and internal signage referencing CWWK’s development roadmap.

The upper floors were used by the R&D and marketing teams. In a dedicated product room, I was shown nearly every motherboard they’ve developed, including legacy models and upcoming releases. Several new boards were in early development, featuring high-density SATA fan-outs via SFF-8654 and NVMe expandability.

Designs ranged from micro-ITX to mATX, with plans to scale modularly using add-on cards for storage and connectivity. I also viewed design schematics and 3D renderings used to plan component layout and case compatibility. CWWK is working on 10GbE-capable models using newer Intel and AMD platforms, including boards with ECC memory support and USB4 integration. While I was not permitted to document everything in detail, the scope and clarity of the development process suggested an active, technically capable engineering team.

After spending a full day across both facilities, my overall impression of CWWK was that of a mid-sized but competent hardware developer with a growing international presence. While the first building’s exact ownership remains somewhat ambiguous, the second building was clearly operated and branded by CWWK, housing their product, development, and marketing teams. More significantly, based on my observations and the responses given, it is clear that CWWK designs and owns the intellectual property behind their motherboards.

There were also strong indications that they serve as an upstream supplier for other brands—likely including companies like Topton, MrRoute, and similar resellers often seen on Chinese e-commerce platforms. Whether these partners act as distributors, integrators, or white-label resellers wasn’t explicitly stated, but the relationship appears to exist.

CWWK is not a shell company or brand-only operation; it is a functioning developer and manufacturer of computing hardware with its own IP, infrastructure, and personnel. For buyers, this doesn’t automatically guarantee performance or support satisfaction, but it does lend some credibility and traceability to a product category often dominated by opaque supply chains and unbranded goods.

📧 SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER 🔔
[contact-form-7]
🔒 Join Inner Circle

Get an alert every time something gets added to this specific article!


Want to follow specific category? 📧 Subscribe

This description contains links to Amazon. These links will take you to some of the products mentioned in today's content. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Visit the NASCompares Deal Finder to find the best place to buy this device in your region, based on Service, Support and Reputation - Just Search for your NAS Drive in the Box Below

Need Advice on Data Storage from an Expert?

Finally, for free advice about your setup, just leave a message in the comments below here at NASCompares.com and we will get back to you. Need Help? Where possible (and where appropriate) please provide as much information about your requirements, as then I can arrange the best answer and solution to your needs. Do not worry about your e-mail address being required, it will NOT be used in a mailing list and will NOT be used in any way other than to respond to your enquiry. [contact-form-7] TRY CHAT Terms and Conditions
If you like this service, please consider supporting us. We use affiliate links on the blog allowing NAScompares information and advice service to be free of charge to you.Anything you purchase on the day you click on our links will generate a small commission which isused to run the website. Here is a link for Amazon and B&H.You can also get me a ☕ Ko-fi or old school Paypal. Thanks!To find out more about how to support this advice service check HEREIf you need to fix or configure a NAS, check Fiver Have you thought about helping others with your knowledge? Find Instructions Here  
 
Or support us by using our affiliate links on Amazon UK and Amazon US
    
 
Alternatively, why not ask me on the ASK NASCompares forum, by clicking the button below. This is a community hub that serves as a place that I can answer your question, chew the fat, share new release information and even get corrections posted. I will always get around to answering ALL queries, but as a one-man operation, I cannot promise speed! So by sharing your query in the ASK NASCompares section below, you can get a better range of solutions and suggestions, alongside my own.

☕ WE LOVE COFFEE ☕

 

N305 6-Bay 10GbE NAS Motherboard Review – BUDGET BRILLIANT DIY NAS BUILD?

Par : Rob Andrews
20 décembre 2024 à 18:00

The N305 M-ITX NAS Motherboard with 10GbE – Should You Buy It?

If you’re considering a custom NAS or server build, the N305 M-ITX NAS Motherboard with 10GbE offers an enticing mix of performance, power efficiency, and networking prowess. Designed with modern demands in mind, it combines Intel’s Alder Lake-N processors with a robust set of connectivity options, including a standout 10GbE port. Whether for personal media servers, small office NAS setups, or edge computing, this motherboard brings noteworthy improvements over its predecessors. Let’s explore its design, hardware, connectivity, and practical applications.

NOTE 1 – A version of this motherboard has appeared that features a x4 PCIe slot, but it is shared with the 2nd M.2 slot. You can learn more about it HERE on the Amazon listing

NOTE 2 – The review of the N100 version of this motherboard is now live and HERE on YouTube and HERE on the blog

 


Where to Buy the 10GbE N300/N305 NAS MoBo?
  • Aliexpress $138.96 (N100 10GbE, No Memory or SSD) – HERE
  • Aliexpress $214.99 (N300 10GbE, 8GB Memory, 128GB OS SSD) – HERE
  • Check Amazon HERE

Topton MW-N305-NAS ITX DiY NAS Review – Quick Conclusion

The Topton MW-N305-NAS motherboard is an affordable M-ITX option for basic NAS setups, featuring a low-power yet high capability 8 core i3 CPU, dual 2.5GbE ports, and a rare built-in 10GbE port for faster data transfer. With six SATA ports and two M.2 slots, it offers versatile storage options, although the M.2 slots are limited to PCIe Gen 3 x1, restricting maximum speeds. While the lack of a PCIe slot and ECC support may limit its appeal for advanced users, the N305 10G NAS board performs reliably for general NAS tasks like file storage, backups, and moderate streaming. It’s best suited for budget-conscious users who need a compact and low-power NAS with decent networking options, though not for those requiring extensive expandability or high-speed processing. It’s a shame about the lack of PCIe upgradability (there is a split m.2/PCIe x4 version from Topton in the market), but aside from that, it is incredibly difficult to fault this value 10GbE DIY NAS offering!

BUILD QUALITY - 8/10
HARDWARE - 8/10
PERFORMANCE - 7/10
PRICE - 10/10
VALUE - 9/10


8.4
PROS
👍🏻Affordable price for an ITX motherboard with 10GbE networking capabilities.
👍🏻Built-in 10GbE port (Marvell AQC113C) and dual 2.5GbE ports (Intel i226-V) for versatile networking options.
👍🏻Low power consumption (6W TDP for CPU), suitable for continuous 24/7 operation.
👍🏻Six SATA 3.0 ports and two M.2 NVMe slots, providing flexible storage configuration options.
👍🏻Compact form factor, making it ideal for small NAS builds and limited-space installations.
👍🏻Supports up to 32GB of DDR5 memory, which is adequate for general NAS use.
👍🏻Low heat output with stable thermal performance, reducing the need for extensive cooling.
👍🏻User-friendly BIOS with customization options for PCI and USB settings.
CONS
👎🏻No PCIe slot, limiting expansion options for additional hardware like GPUs or other high-speed components.
👎🏻Lacks ECC memory support, which is often preferred in NAS setups for data integrity.
👎🏻M.2 slots are limited to PCIe Gen 3 x1 lanes, restricting maximum speed for high-performance applications.
👎🏻Requires a 300W power supply despite low power demands, adding potential extra cost and size requirements.


Where to Buy a Product
amzamexmaestrovisamaster 24Hfree delreturn VISIT RETAILER ➤ 
amzamexmaestrovisamaster 24Hfree delreturn VISIT RETAILER ➤


N305 M-ITX NAS Motherboard – Design and Build Quality

The N305 10GbE motherboard adheres to the Mini-ITX standard (17cm x 17cm), making it an excellent choice for compact builds. Its matte black PCB not only enhances aesthetic appeal but also signifies durability, with an 8-layer high-density fiber design that provides resistance against environmental stressors like moisture. This level of build quality ensures long-term reliability, critical for 24/7 NAS operation or server usage.

One of the key selling points of this model is its ability to balance compactness with functionality. Despite its small footprint, the board integrates a range of advanced components, including the Intel Alder Lake-N N305 CPU and a robust networking stack.

Thermal management is supported with well-placed headers for CPU and system cooling fans, ensuring stable performance even under continuous operation.

A notable upgrade in this model is the inclusion of a 10GbE LAN port, alongside two 2.5GbE ports. These features position the N305 as a professional-grade option, capable of handling demanding data transfer and network management tasks. The board also supports dual M.2 NVMe slots and six SATA3.0 ports, offering ample storage flexibility for SSDs and HDDs alike.

Component Details
CPU Intel Alder Lake-N N305, 8 Threads, 3.8 GHz boost
Memory 1x SO-DIMM DDR5 (4800-5600MHz), up to 32GB
Networking 1x 10GbE (Marvell AQC113C), 2x 2.5GbE (Intel i226-V)
Storage 6x SATA3.0, 2x M.2 NVMe (PCIe 3.0, 2280)
Graphics Intel UHD Graphics, 4K@60Hz via HDMI 2.1 and DP 1.4b
Power ATX 24+4 Pin, minimum 300W PSU recommended

With its thoughtful design and robust specifications, the N305 10GbE motherboard proves to be a versatile and compact solution for users requiring reliability and high performance in a small form factor.


N305 M-ITX NAS Motherboard – Processor and Performance

The heart of this motherboard is the Intel Alder Lake-N N305 processor, an 8-thread chip with a maximum clock speed of 3.8 GHz. Designed with efficiency in mind, it features a modest TDP of 9-15W, making it ideal for systems running 24/7.

This processor delivers the computational power needed for a wide range of applications, from lightweight virtualization to handling multiple network clients in a NAS setup. I tested the N305 NAS mobo and below are the stats power consumption numbers for both IDLE and 30-50% power use with all drives in use. Testing revealed idle power consumption of just 27-28 watts with six connected drives in hibernation, and a peak utilization of 64-66 watts under heavy RAID 5 operations across six hard drives via 10GbE.

Built on Intel’s Alder Lake-N architecture, the N305 achieves a balance between energy efficiency and performance. This makes it particularly suitable for edge computing, media streaming, and private cloud hosting. Whether you’re transcoding videos for Plex or running containerized workloads in Docker, this CPU handles it all with ease. Additionally, the integrated Intel UHD Graphics (32 execution units) ensures smooth playback of 4K media.

Memory performance on this board is another highlight. The single SO-DIMM DDR5 slot supports frequencies up to 5600MHz and capacities of up to 32GB, delivering fast data access speeds. This enables seamless multitasking and rapid handling of large files, critical for NAS environments where throughput is essential. While the single memory slot may limit scalability for some, it fits well with the board’s compact and power-efficient design. That said, even with it’s more affordable price, the lack of ECC memory support (both a CPU and MoBo limitation) is going to be a dealbreaker for storage veterans.

The N305’s low power consumption doesn’t compromise its capabilities. It can handle a surprising range of tasks for a CPU of its class, making it suitable for both personal and small business setups. The combination of processing power, efficiency, and modern architecture makes this motherboard a compelling choice for users looking to maximize performance without incurring high energy costs.


M-ITX NAS Motherboard – Ports and Connections

Ports and connections are a critical factor for any motherboard, and the N305 doesn’t disappoint. Its rear I/O panel includes a rich mix of options, catering to various connectivity needs.

The standout feature is the 10GbE LAN port, supported by the Marvell AQC113C chipset, which is complemented by two 2.5GbE LAN ports for additional network flexibility.

This combination allows users to configure advanced setups, such as load balancing or link aggregation.

For display outputs, the board features HDMI 2.1 and DisplayPort 1.4b, both supporting 4K@60Hz resolution. These ports ensure crisp visuals for administrative tasks, media playback, or light graphical workloads. Additionally, a 3.5mm audio jack powered by the Realtek ALC897 codec provides basic audio output, suitable for most NAS or server setups.

USB connectivity includes a mix of USB 3.0 and USB 2.0 ports, alongside a Type-C port (albeit limited to USB 2.0 speeds). Internally, headers for additional USB ports and front-panel connectivity provide customization options, enhancing the board’s adaptability for various builds.

Port Type Details
LAN 1x 10GbE, 2x 2.5GbE
Display HDMI 2.1, DP 1.4b (4K@60Hz support)
USB 1x USB 3.0, 2x USB 2.0, 1x Type-C (USB 2.0 rate)
Audio 3.5mm jack (Realtek ALC897 codec)
Internal Headers USB 2.0, fan control, front panel

Internally, the motherboard is equipped with headers for fan control, USB expansion, and front-panel connections, ensuring that builders can optimize cooling and functionality. The thoughtful inclusion of multiple ports and expansion headers makes the N305 10GbE motherboard suitable for a wide range of applications, from data-intensive NAS setups to compact home labs.


M-ITX NAS Motherboard – Storage Capabilities

Storage flexibility is one of the N305’s strongest features. The board includes six SATA3.0 ports, capable of speeds up to 6Gbps, ideal for building RAID arrays or connecting multiple high-capacity drives.

These ports are managed by the JMB585 controller, which ensures efficient throughput and compatibility with various storage devices.

The two M.2 NVMe slots provide high-speed storage options for caching or boot drives. These slots are PCIe 3.0 x1, supporting 2280-sized drives, and deliver sequential read/write speeds sufficient for most NAS or server needs.

#However, one M.2 slot shares its signal with the PCIe x1 lane, requiring users to carefully plan resource allocation depending on their build priorities.

The storage setup also supports features like TRIM for SSDs and port multiplier configurations, allowing users to expand their storage options further. This is particularly useful for creating large-scale NAS setups, where maximizing drive connectivity is a priority.

The performance of the MW-N305-NAS motherboard showcases a balance of efficiency and capability for its price point.  Storage speeds on the six SATA ports, powered by a JMB 58x controller on a Gen 3×1 lane, achieved sequential read and write rates of approximately 495 MB/s and 350-380 MB/s respectively.

While the 10GbE Aquantia AQC113C controller delivered fully saturated 10GbE throughput, the advertised USB 20Gbps port fell short, maxing out at 1GB/s during tests. Despite its modest clock speeds and limited PCIe lanes, the MW-N305-NAS excels as a cost-effective, low-power NAS motherboard for DIY builders, especially when considering its compact ITX form factor and versatile connectivity. In short – SATA HDD performance over the single 10GbE connection was pretty standard and acceptable, and the 3×1 lane allocation to each m.2 resulted in the expected sub 1GB internal throughput. The two M.2 NVMe slots, also Gen 3×1, reached read speeds of 783 MB/s and write speeds around 655-690 MB/s, performing consistently within the bandwidth constraints.

Transferring data between each m.2 SSD inside the system (1GB repeated file write) dropped performance down noticeably, but again – this was largely expected and based on the lane speed downgrades, hardly surprising.

Storage Type Details
SATA Ports 6x SATA3.0 (6Gbps), JMB585 controller
M.2 NVMe 2x PCIe 3.0 x1 slots (2280 size)
TRIM Support Yes
Port Multiplier Yes

Whether for storing media libraries, backing up critical data, or running virtual machines, the N305 offers a robust and flexible storage solution. Despite its compact size, the board’s thoughtful design ensures that users can configure it for both speed and capacity. This makes it a compelling option for anyone looking to build a high-performance, high-capacity NAS or server, with the flexibility to scale storage as needed.


The N305 10GbE Motherboard – Should You Buy It?

As of 2024, the N305 M-ITX NAS motherboard with 10GbE represents a versatile and cost-effective platform for users seeking a combination of performance, power efficiency, and robust connectivity. With its Alder Lake-N processor, DDR5 memory support, and standout 10GbE networking capabilities, it delivers exceptional value for its price. This motherboard is particularly well-suited for applications like Plex Media Server, Proxmox virtual machines, or UnRAID/TrueNAS setups, where both processing power and network bandwidth are critical. Its comprehensive storage options and energy-efficient design further solidify its place as a top contender in the compact NAS and server motherboard market.

However, users with high expansion needs or enterprise-level requirements may find its PCIe lane limitations a challenge. For most small-scale and prosumer applications, though, it strikes an excellent balance between capability and efficiency. Whether you’re building a new media server or upgrading an existing NAS, the N305 10GbE motherboard is a strong choice that offers modern features and flexibility in a compact package.

PROS CONs
  • Affordable price for an ITX motherboard with 10GbE networking capabilities.
  • Built-in 10GbE port (Marvell AQC113C) and dual 2.5GbE ports (Intel i226-V) for versatile networking options.
  • Low power consumption (6-10W TDP for CPU), suitable for continuous 24/7 operation.
  • Six SATA 3.0 ports and two M.2 NVMe slots, providing flexible storage configuration options.
  • Compact form factor, making it ideal for small NAS builds and limited-space installations.
  • Supports up to 32GB of DDR5 memory, which is adequate for general NAS use.
  • Low heat output with stable thermal performance, reducing the need for extensive cooling.
  • User-friendly BIOS with customization options for PCI and USB settings.
  • No PCIe slot, limiting expansion options for additional hardware like GPUs or other high-speed components.
  • Lacks ECC memory support, which is often preferred in NAS setups for data integrity.
  • M.2 slots are limited to PCIe Gen 3 x1 lanes, restricting maximum speed for high-performance applications.

 

📧 SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER 🔔
[contact-form-7]
🔒 Join Inner Circle

Get an alert every time something gets added to this specific article!


Want to follow specific category? 📧 Subscribe

This description contains links to Amazon. These links will take you to some of the products mentioned in today's content. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Visit the NASCompares Deal Finder to find the best place to buy this device in your region, based on Service, Support and Reputation - Just Search for your NAS Drive in the Box Below

Need Advice on Data Storage from an Expert?

Finally, for free advice about your setup, just leave a message in the comments below here at NASCompares.com and we will get back to you. Need Help? Where possible (and where appropriate) please provide as much information about your requirements, as then I can arrange the best answer and solution to your needs. Do not worry about your e-mail address being required, it will NOT be used in a mailing list and will NOT be used in any way other than to respond to your enquiry. [contact-form-7] TRY CHAT Terms and Conditions
If you like this service, please consider supporting us. We use affiliate links on the blog allowing NAScompares information and advice service to be free of charge to you.Anything you purchase on the day you click on our links will generate a small commission which isused to run the website. Here is a link for Amazon and B&H.You can also get me a ☕ Ko-fi or old school Paypal. Thanks!To find out more about how to support this advice service check HEREIf you need to fix or configure a NAS, check Fiver Have you thought about helping others with your knowledge? Find Instructions Here  
 
Or support us by using our affiliate links on Amazon UK and Amazon US
    
 
Alternatively, why not ask me on the ASK NASCompares forum, by clicking the button below. This is a community hub that serves as a place that I can answer your question, chew the fat, share new release information and even get corrections posted. I will always get around to answering ALL queries, but as a one-man operation, I cannot promise speed! So by sharing your query in the ASK NASCompares section below, you can get a better range of solutions and suggestions, alongside my own.

☕ WE LOVE COFFEE ☕

 

Recommended ATX Motherboards for DIY NAS Builds

Par : Rob Andrews
13 décembre 2024 à 16:00

Six ATX/MATX/EATX Motherboards for Your BYO NAS Build

Building your own NAS (Network Attached Storage) offers unparalleled control over your storage solution, but choosing the right motherboard is crucial. While ITX motherboards are commonly used for compact builds, ATX motherboards excel in scalability and performance. This guide explores six top ATX motherboards suitable for DIY NAS builders and explains why ATX might be the right choice for your project.


ATX vs. ITX: Understanding the Differences for NAS Use

ITX motherboards have long been favored for NAS systems due to their compact size, lower power consumption, and often pre-included mobile CPUs. These features make them ideal for smaller, quieter builds with minimal hardware requirements. However, ITX boards typically offer fewer PCIe slots, fewer SATA ports, and limited M.2 storage options, which can restrict scalability for larger storage systems. In contrast, ATX motherboards shine in builds where storage and expansion are priorities. They offer multiple PCIe slots for RAID cards, network cards, and GPUs, along with extensive SATA and M.2 connectivity. While ATX motherboards tend to consume more power and require larger cases, they cater to the growing demands of NAS builders who need flexibility and performance. If you’re planning to scale your NAS system or integrate high-speed networking, ATX is often the better choice despite its higher price point and larger physical footprint.

Motherboard form factors play a critical role in determining a system’s size, expandability, and compatibility. mATX (Micro-ATX), ATX (Advanced Technology Extended), and E-ATX (Extended ATX) represent progressively larger sizes, each catering to different use cases. mATX motherboards are compact and typically measure 9.6 × 9.6 inches, making them ideal for small cases and builds that prioritize a smaller footprint. However, they often sacrifice expandability, offering fewer PCIe slots, SATA ports, and overall connectivity. Standard ATX motherboards, measuring 12 × 9.6 inches, strike a balance between size and functionality, providing ample room for multiple PCIe slots, more storage options, and better cooling configurations. Finally, E-ATX motherboards, measuring up to 12 × 13 inches, cater to high-performance builds such as workstations or enterprise systems. They offer additional PCIe lanes, memory slots, and connectivity options but require larger cases and often consume more power. The choice between these form factors depends on your specific needs for expandability, performance, and the physical constraints of your build.


1. MSI MAG B550 Tomahawk

VALUE OPTION – AMD Ryzen Support, 6 SATA Ports, 2 M.2 NVMe Slots (Gen 4 + Gen 3), 2.5GbE + 1GbE LAN, DDR4 ECC Support, ATX, Multiple USB Ports – $160 (HERE)

The MSI MAG B550 Tomahawk is a reliable and feature-rich entry-level motherboard that provides excellent value for small to medium NAS setups. Built on AMD’s B550 chipset, it supports Ryzen 3000, 4000, and 5000 series processors, giving builders access to high-performance CPUs. The board can accommodate up to 128GB of DDR4 memory, with ECC support ensuring data integrity for critical storage applications. This feature is particularly important for NAS systems, where even minor data corruption can lead to significant issues.

On the storage front, the B550 Tomahawk offers six SATA III ports and two M.2 slots, providing ample options for both traditional hard drives and high-speed NVMe SSDs. The primary M.2 slot supports PCIe Gen 4, delivering up to 64Gbps of bandwidth, making it ideal for caching or handling high-speed data operations. The second M.2 slot, while limited to PCIe Gen 3, is still more than capable for secondary drives or less demanding workloads. Its two PCIe x16 slots enable expansion options, such as adding a GPU for transcoding or a RAID controller for additional storage management.

The networking setup includes one 2.5GbE and one 1GbE port, sufficient for home NAS systems or small-scale offices. While the board lacks advanced connectivity features like Thunderbolt or Wi-Fi, its affordability (around $160) makes it an attractive choice for budget-conscious builders. Additionally, the board’s user-friendly BIOS and comprehensive I/O options ensure ease of setup and compatibility with a wide range of components.

Specification Details
Socket AM4
Chipset AMD B550
Max Memory 128GB DDR4 (ECC support)
SATA Ports 6
M.2 Slots 2 (1× Gen 4, 1× Gen 3)
PCIe Slots 2× PCIe x16, 2× PCIe x1
Ethernet Ports 1× 2.5GbE, 1× 1GbE
Price ~$160
Form Factor ATX

2. ASRock IMB-X1314

Good Middle Ground Choice – Intel 12th-14th Gen Processor Support, 8 SATA Ports, 2 M.2 NVMe Slots (Gen 4), 3x 2.5GbE LAN, DDR4 ECC Support, Micro-ATX, TPM & USB Ports – $350 (HERE)

The ASRock IMB-X1314 is a professional-grade motherboard that provides exceptional features tailored for NAS and server builds. Designed to support Intel’s 12th to 14th Gen processors, it accommodates up to 128GB of DDR4 ECC memory, ensuring optimal reliability for storage applications. This board is particularly appealing for users who require a robust, scalable solution for high-capacity and data-intensive environments.

For storage, the IMB-X1314 features eight SATA III ports and two M.2 slots. The SATA ports allow for large-scale HDD arrays, perfect for archival storage or bulk data retention, while the M.2 slots provide fast NVMe SSD options for caching or active data operations. Both M.2 slots support PCIe Gen 4, ensuring maximum performance for modern SSDs. Its PCIe layout includes a x16 slot for GPUs or RAID controllers, a x8 slot for additional expansion, and two x4 slots for networking cards or storage accelerators.

Networking is a strong point for the IMB-X1314, with three 2.5GbE ports. These ports enable link aggregation for increased throughput or allow the board to handle multiple subnets, catering to advanced network setups. Security and management features, including onboard TPM 2.0 and Intel vPro support, make this board suitable for enterprise-grade use cases.

Despite its $350 price point, the IMB-X1314 offers excellent value for its advanced features. The robust design and wide range of I/O options ensure compatibility with modern components, while its efficient power delivery system minimizes energy costs for 24/7 operation.

Specification Details
Socket LGA 1700
Chipset Intel W680
Max Memory 128GB DDR4 (ECC support)
SATA Ports 8
M.2 Slots 2
PCIe Slots 1× PCIe x16, 1× PCIe x8, 2× PCIe x4
Ethernet Ports 3× 2.5GbE
Price ~$350
Form Factor Micro-ATX

3. ASRock Z890 NOVA WiFi

Good Affordable Flash Solution – Intel Z890 Chipset, 4 SATA Ports, 5 M.2 NVMe Slots (Gen 5 + Gen 4), 5GbE + 2.5GbE LAN, DDR5 Support, ATX, Thunderbolt 4 + WiFi 7 – $450 (HERE)

The ASRock Z890 NOVA WiFi is a state-of-the-art motherboard designed for high-performance NAS setups. Featuring Intel’s Z890 chipset, it supports up to 256GB of DDR5 memory, offering unmatched performance for memory-intensive applications. Its compatibility with the latest Intel processors ensures builders can harness cutting-edge technology for their NAS.

In terms of storage, the Z890 NOVA boasts five M.2 slots, one of which supports PCIe Gen 5, delivering exceptional speeds for NVMe SSDs. The other four slots utilize PCIe Gen 4, making this board ideal for hybrid storage configurations that balance speed and capacity. Additionally, it includes four SATA III ports, accommodating traditional HDDs for bulk storage needs. The robust PCIe layout allows for additional networking cards, RAID controllers, or GPUs, giving builders the flexibility to tailor their system to their specific requirements.

Networking options include a 5GbE and a 2.5GbE port, ensuring reliable, high-speed data transfer. Its Thunderbolt 4 connectivity further enhances its utility, allowing seamless integration with external storage devices or high-speed peripherals. Wi-Fi 7 and Bluetooth 5.4 provide additional wireless options, making the Z890 NOVA suitable for modern, connected environments. At approximately $450, this motherboard offers a perfect blend of performance, scalability, and connectivity for demanding NAS builds.

Specification Details
Socket 1851
Chipset Intel Z890
Max Memory 256GB DDR5
SATA Ports 4
M.2 Slots 5 (1× Gen 5, 4× Gen 4)
PCIe Slots 1× PCIe 5.0 x16, 1× PCIe 4.0 x16
Ethernet Ports 1× 5GbE, 1× 2.5GbE
Price ~$450
Form Factor ATX

4. BKHD-2011-mATX (Refurbished)

Budget Refurbished Option – Intel Xeon E5 Support, 10 SATA Ports, 2 M.2 NVMe Slots, 4x 2.5GbE LAN, DDR4 ECC Support, Micro-ATX, PCIe 3.0 Slots – $320 (HERE)

The BKHD-2011-mATX is a robust, enterprise-oriented motherboard tailored for high-capacity storage and demanding workloads. It is compatible with Intel Xeon E5-2600 v3/v4 processors and supports up to 256GB of DDR4 memory, making it a solid choice for users building NAS systems that require exceptional multitasking and performance. Its support for ECC memory further ensures data integrity, a key requirement for enterprise-grade storage solutions.

This motherboard excels in storage flexibility, featuring ten SATA III ports and two M.2 slots that support NVMe SSDs. The SATA configuration allows for vast storage arrays, ideal for archival or bulk storage purposes, while the M.2 slots provide high-speed access for caching or active workloads. For expansion, it offers two PCIe x16 slots and one PCIe x8 slot, which can be utilized for additional storage controllers, advanced GPUs, or network accelerators.

Networking is another highlight of the BKHD-2011-mATX. Equipped with four 2.5GbE LAN ports, it can handle large data transfers across multiple networks or subnets. This makes it an excellent choice for virtualization environments or NAS systems supporting multiple clients. Despite its older architecture, it remains a compelling option due to its affordability, typically priced around $320. For users looking to build a NAS with enterprise-level capabilities on a budget, the BKHD-2011-mATX delivers outstanding value.

Specification Details
Socket LGA 2011-3
Chipset Intel C612
Max Memory 256GB DDR4 (ECC support)
SATA Ports 10
M.2 Slots 2
PCIe Slots 2× PCIe x16, 1× PCIe x8
Ethernet Ports 4× 2.5GbE
Price ~$320
Form Factor Micro-ATX

5. MSI MEG Z790 GODLIKE

Premium Flash Solution – Intel Z790 Chipset, 6 SATA Ports, 7 M.2 NVMe Slots (Gen 5 + Gen 4), 10GbE + 2.5GbE LAN, DDR5 Support, E-ATX, Thunderbolt 4 Ports – $800 (HERE)

The MSI MEG Z790 GODLIKE is a premium motherboard designed for builders seeking top-tier performance and scalability. Powered by Intel’s Z790 chipset, it supports Intel 12th, 13th, and 14th Gen processors and accommodates up to 256GB of DDR5 memory. With its ECC memory support and robust power delivery system, this board is well-suited for high-performance NAS systems handling mission-critical data.

The GODLIKE excels in storage, offering seven M.2 slots, one of which supports PCIe Gen 5 for unmatched NVMe SSD speeds. The remaining six slots are PCIe Gen 4, ensuring fast and efficient data access. Additionally, six SATA III ports provide ample options for traditional HDDs, making this board suitable for hybrid storage configurations. Its PCIe layout includes two x16 Gen 5 slots, enabling seamless integration of GPUs or advanced RAID controllers.

For networking, the Z790 GODLIKE features dual Ethernet ports—a 10GbE and a 2.5GbE—ensuring ultra-fast data transfers and high reliability. Thunderbolt 4 connectivity expands its utility, supporting high-speed peripherals and external storage devices. Priced at approximately $800, this motherboard targets professionals and enterprise users who require cutting-edge technology and unparalleled scalability.

Specification Details
Socket LGA 1700
Chipset Intel Z790
Max Memory 256GB DDR5 (ECC support)
SATA Ports 6
M.2 Slots 7 (1× Gen 5, 6× Gen 4)
PCIe Slots 2× PCIe 5.0 x16
Ethernet Ports 1× 10GbE, 1× 2.5GbE
Price ~$800
Form Factor E-ATX

6. ASUS Pro WS WRX80E-SAGE SE WiFi

POWERHOUSE VM SERVER – AMD Threadripper PRO Support, 8 SATA Ports, 3 M.2 NVMe Slots (Gen 4), 2x 10GbE LAN, 2TB DDR4 ECC Support, E-ATX, Remote Management – $1,300 (HERE)

The ASUS Pro WS WRX80E-SAGE SE WiFi is the ultimate workstation motherboard for enterprise-grade NAS systems. Built for AMD Ryzen Threadripper PRO processors, it supports up to 2TB of DDR4 ECC memory across eight channels, making it ideal for memory-intensive tasks like virtualization, large-scale data analytics, or multi-user NAS setups. This level of scalability is unmatched, ensuring future-proofing for years to come.

Storage options are equally impressive, with three M.2 PCIe Gen 4 slots, eight SATA III ports, and two U.2 slots capable of supporting NVMe drives. The M.2 slots are optimized for high-speed SSDs, while the SATA and U.2 ports provide bulk storage options, making it ideal for hybrid setups. Its seven PCIe 4.0 x16 slots allow for maximum expansion, accommodating GPUs, high-speed networking cards, and RAID controllers simultaneously.

Networking is handled by dual 10GbE LAN ports, ensuring seamless data transfer even under heavy loads. For remote management, the board includes ASMB9-iKVM, enabling hardware-level control through IPMI. Priced at $1,300, the WRX80E-SAGE SE WiFi is a high-end solution designed for enterprise users who demand unparalleled performance, reliability, and scalability.

Specification Details
Socket sWRX8
Chipset AMD WRX80
Max Memory 2TB DDR4 (ECC support)
SATA Ports 8
M.2 Slots 3
PCIe Slots 7× PCIe 4.0 x16
Ethernet Ports 2× 10GbE
Price ~$1,300
Form Factor E-ATX

Each of these motherboards offers unique features and configurations tailored to specific NAS requirements, ranging from budget-friendly options to high-performance enterprise solutions. Selecting the right board depends on your specific needs for scalability, storage, and networking capabilities. With the detailed specifications provided, you can confidently choose the best motherboard for your DIY NAS project.

📧 SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER 🔔
[contact-form-7]
🔒 Join Inner Circle

Get an alert every time something gets added to this specific article!


Want to follow specific category? 📧 Subscribe

This description contains links to Amazon. These links will take you to some of the products mentioned in today's content. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Visit the NASCompares Deal Finder to find the best place to buy this device in your region, based on Service, Support and Reputation - Just Search for your NAS Drive in the Box Below

Need Advice on Data Storage from an Expert?

Finally, for free advice about your setup, just leave a message in the comments below here at NASCompares.com and we will get back to you. Need Help? Where possible (and where appropriate) please provide as much information about your requirements, as then I can arrange the best answer and solution to your needs. Do not worry about your e-mail address being required, it will NOT be used in a mailing list and will NOT be used in any way other than to respond to your enquiry. [contact-form-7] TRY CHAT Terms and Conditions
If you like this service, please consider supporting us. We use affiliate links on the blog allowing NAScompares information and advice service to be free of charge to you.Anything you purchase on the day you click on our links will generate a small commission which isused to run the website. Here is a link for Amazon and B&H.You can also get me a ☕ Ko-fi or old school Paypal. Thanks!To find out more about how to support this advice service check HEREIf you need to fix or configure a NAS, check Fiver Have you thought about helping others with your knowledge? Find Instructions Here  
 
Or support us by using our affiliate links on Amazon UK and Amazon US
    
 
Alternatively, why not ask me on the ASK NASCompares forum, by clicking the button below. This is a community hub that serves as a place that I can answer your question, chew the fat, share new release information and even get corrections posted. I will always get around to answering ALL queries, but as a one-man operation, I cannot promise speed! So by sharing your query in the ASK NASCompares section below, you can get a better range of solutions and suggestions, alongside my own.

☕ WE LOVE COFFEE ☕

 

Phalcomm / STUDEVOX L8 NAS Case Review

Par : Rob Andrews
11 décembre 2024 à 18:00

Phalcomm / STUDEVOX L8 NAS Case Review

Building your own NAS server from scratch is an endeavor largely made up of two main hurdles: choosing the inside and choosing the outside! Most of the time, the hardest choices are going to be picking the right CPU, the right motherboard, the right connections, and of course, provisioning for your storage plans. However, all of those great decisions you make on picking the inside of your server can be immediately undermined if you make poor choices on the enclosure that you choose to use for your DIY NAS. One brand that hopes to earn the right to store your data is Phalcomm, with a new compact NAS server enclosure. Arriving at around $150 to $200, this is about average for a DIY 8-bay NAS box in 2024/2025. So, what does this brand hope to provide in its NAS enclosure that you can’t just get elsewhere? That’s what today’s review is about, and hopefully, by the end of this review, you’ll decide whether the Phalcomm L8 deserves your data.

Phalcomm / STUDEVOX L8 8-Bay NAS Case Review – Quick Conclusion

The Phalcomm L8 NAS case provides a solid, compact option for DIY NAS builders, accommodating both ITX and ATX motherboards while supporting up to eight SATA drives. Its design is straightforward, featuring a durable steel enclosure with extensive passive ventilation on all sides, allowing for efficient airflow. With multiple fan mounting options—up to five fans can be installed—users have the flexibility to enhance cooling based on their specific needs. Inside, the case offers a spacious layout, making it easy to install components such as the motherboard, CPU cooler (up to 158mm in height), and PSU. However, some drawbacks include the absence of pre-installed fans, which competitors often include at a similar price point, and a lack of front-mounted features like drive trays or LCD panels. Additionally, the case does not come with essential cables like SATA or power, requiring further investment to complete the setup. Overall, the Phalcomm L8 is a well-constructed enclosure with room for customization, though users should be prepared for extra expenses to fully optimize its performance and functionality.

BUILD QUALITY - 7/10
DURABILITY - 8/10
EXPANDABILITY - 8/10
PRICE - 7/10
VALUE - 7/10


7.4
PROS
👍🏻Compact Design: Despite supporting eight SATA drives and ITX/ATX motherboards, the case is surprisingly compact compared to other NAS enclosures.
👍🏻Flexible Motherboard Support: Compatible with both ITX and ATX motherboards, offering flexibility for different build configurations.
👍🏻Extensive Ventilation: Features passive ventilation on every side, ensuring good airflow and potential for keeping components cool.
👍🏻Multiple Fan Mounting Options: The case has five optional fan mounting locations, allowing for customizable active cooling.
👍🏻Spacious Interior: Provides plenty of room for motherboard and CPU cooler installation, supporting CPU coolers up to 158mm in height.
👍🏻PCIe Expansion Support: Includes several PCIe expansion slots for additional components, allowing for future upgrades.
👍🏻Easy Access for Installation: Removable storage cage and clear internal layout make motherboard and component installation straightforward.
👍🏻Unique PSU Mounting: The PSU is mounted with copper risers to ensure proper airflow and space management, preventing overheating.
CONS
👎🏻No Included Fans: Unlike some competitors, the Phalcomm L8 doesn’t come with any pre-installed fans, requiring additional purchases for active cooling.
👎🏻Limited Front Features: The front panel lacks typical NAS features such as ejectable trays, LCD panels, or drive indicators.
👎🏻Tight Fan Fit in the Front Cavity: Space is limited for front fans, which may lead to less-than-ideal installation, impacting airflow.
👎🏻No Included Cables: The case does not come with SATA or power cables, which are essential for setting up the system.


Phalcomm / STUDEVOX L8 Case Review – Design

The enclosure design is actually pretty ordinary, and it’s only when you realize that this system can house eight SATA storage drives and supports both ITX and ATX motherboards that the deceptively compact enclosure stands out. Arriving a fraction smaller than a number of other ATX motherboard-supporting NAS boxes in the market, this system has a relatively unique approach to drive injection that I will touch on later in more detail.

The front of the system is surprisingly low in detail compared with other NAS chassis. For example, there is a complete lack of front-mounted ejectable trays. The system features a front-mounted USB and its power button, but that’s really it. No included LCD panel, and little to no drive indication immediately visible. The casing is 1mm thick steel, in matte black, but is not available in any other color currently.

What the case does feature in excess is passive ventilation. With the exception of the base of the enclosure, the L8 features ventilation on every single side. Absolutely tons of passive airflow are going to be possible in every direction on this case when it is deployed. Passive ventilation is only half the battle, of course, as you will still need to factor in active cooling systems with strategically placed fans in order to facilitate that airflow throughout your components and ensure that the system remains at a highly operable and efficient temperature. However, it’s worth highlighting that the system does not actually include any fans with the enclosure.

The case includes numerous screw holes and included screws for mounting fans in several different locations of the enclosure, but you are going to need to purchase these fans separately. For example, underneath the top panel of this enclosure, we find a rigid framing panel that rests over the top of the motherboard section and allows you to install two 120mm fans to supply active airflow to the motherboard.

Likewise, the rear of the enclosure also features screw holes for an 80mm fan to be mounted to draw further airflow across the internal components of the L8.

Finally, the front panel of the L8 can be removed to expose two individual 120mm fan mounting areas. This brings the total number of optional fans that you can mount on this system to five, which is pretty impressive for such a compact NAS chassis. Nevertheless, it does seem a little cheap for this system to not include even a single fan, when comparative NAS enclosures from brands such as Jonsbo and Highpoint all include active cooling fans alongside the empty enclosures as standard, at a similar price to this.

Additionally, you have to be a little selective on the fans that you plan to install in the front cavity, as space is a little compact. Although fans can technically be mounted on the inside of the enclosure to accommodate slightly larger models, this does protrude into the internal hardware a little and is far less desirable.

I can’t really fault the overall chassis design of the L8 in what it’s trying to achieve in providing a large scope for different NAS hardware configurations, but I really do wish the brand had put their hand in their pocket a little more and supplied active cooling fans with this NAS enclosure. Let’s discuss the internal build architecture of the L8.

Phalcomm / STUDEVOX L8 Case – Inside

The top of the chassis is held in place by two screws on the rear of the enclosure, which, when removed, completely expose the L8’s internal motherboard, PCIe, and PSU installation sections, as well as the 8-bay storage cage that is mounted on two sides to the edges of the enclosure casing.

In order to access the cavity for installing your motherboard, you are going to need to remove that SATA storage cage. The system arrives with the cage fitted directly to an internal PCB that features individual data and power inputs. However, the system does not arrive with SATA cables, Molex power cables, or any of the small but crucial extras you are going to need to build a NAS here. Removing the SATA cage temporarily shows us the full internal cavity and all of the individual mounting screws for different kinds of motherboards clearly accessible.

There’s actually a fairly massive amount of space afforded to the motherboard and CPU cooler installation. This enclosure supports CPU coolers up to 158mm in height, which is pretty generous for both ITX and ATX NAS motherboard deployment. I will touch on slight spacing concerns between the CPU cooler and the PSU later on, but for now, you can see via the image below just how much space is afforded to you and how little space an MITX motherboard takes up when installed inside here, even with my tallest CPU cooler installed.

Likewise, even when I installed an M-ATX motherboard, there was still plenty of room to play with, and as long as you aren’t going to be utilizing a particularly aggressive CPU cooler on your 24/7 NAS server deployment, there’s lots of room for growth here.

Additionally, despite this case being a little compact, it features a myriad of PCIe expansion slots that can be punched out on the exterior of the enclosure. Thanks to modern PCIe risers, intelligently built expansion cards, and M.2 to PCIe adaptors in the market, it’s actually surprisingly easy these days for a NAS user to find ways and means to fully utilize all of that PCIe upgradable goodness.

This, however, leads me to the installation of the PSU/internal power supply in this system. In order for its rather compact design to work, certain creative choices have been made to install a PSU comfortably around the other components. Like a few other more compact NAS enclosures on the market from well-established brands, the L8 features an internal mains power extension cable. This means that although the external rear casing features a mains power female socket, it is in reality feeding into an extension cable to the location of the PSU block, which actually lives at the front right of the chassis.

The mounting of the PSU inside the L8 case is actually a little unique. The PSU is held at the top of the casing via four individual copper risers that not only hold the PSU in place in its raised position but also ensure that the PSU is around 1-2cm away from the enclosure wall, ensuring enough space to use the angled mains power cable correctly while still ensuring that the PSU fan is angled appropriately toward the enclosure’s ventilation panel.

Nevertheless, we DO need to discuss the elephant in the room. Namely, the proximity and placement generally of the PSU in conjunction with the CPU Cooler. IF you plan on using a lower profile CPU cooler, then this will be zero issue at all. However, the maximum of the CPU cooler size and PSU (namely 158mm and 160mm respectively) result in a tremendously close placement of the CPU fan and the internal PSU.

This is by no means a deal breaker, but it is worth keeping this in mind when looking at a compact case like this that it can impact a lot of the component placement. A NAS is designed to be on 24×7 so there is of course the argument that high end power-use deployment is not going to be as common as gamer PC building, so larger CPU heatsinks and powerhouse PSUs are less used in server use (electricity bills!), but there is no avoiding that the placement of the PSU and CPU fan are, in efforts to keep this case compact, very close indeed!

The F Panel cable is fairly standard, but its a little bit of a shame that it only supports 5Gb/s and USB Type A only (so no USB-C or 10Gb/s USB 3.2 Gen 2 support – which is increasingly common on even the most modest NAS optimized mobos from Topton, CWWK, etc). Not ‘bad’, but a little underwhelming for the price in 2024/2025.

Overall, you cannot fault the build quality internally, but the scope of deployment and how much you can do with the afforded space is oddly conflicted. Let’s discuss the storage capabilities of the phalcomm L8 NAS Case.

Phalcomm / STUDEVOX L8 Case Review – Storage

This is possibly the things that left me so hot/cold about the Phalcomm NAS Case. On the face of it, ATX Mobo NAS cases are oddly rare when compared to the range/availability of more compact M-ITX NAS enclosures – even more so when you factor in that the L8 is trying to be a compact MATX/ATX NAS case. Nevertheless, I am a little perplexed by some of the design choices here. The choice of drive injection is unique! It’s convenient, saves on wasted materials towards HDD/SSD Trays and allows for very, very easy to access storage media bays.

Additionally, the 8x SATA media bays also feature a magnetic dust capture panel that can be applied above the HDD bays in order to reduce detritus build up over time. However, this panel definitely feels a little cheap and does not quite sit neatly above the HDD bays. I always had to carefully lay the panel over the HDD cavity to ensure it neatly covered it – it never felt particularly premium. I know how ‘precious’ that sounds, but the panel is not rigid, so if you do not specifically lay out the panel over the cavity ‘corner to cover’, it just ends up looking a little slap-dash. I am glad its there, but I wish this panel was rigia and felt for ‘cut to shape’.

Another thing I have mixed feelings over is the way in which the HDDs are injected into the L8 SATA Drive cage. Each drive needs 2x HDD clips to be attached (3 screws each) and that allows each drive to slide into the runners on each bay – this is all well and good. However, these clips are not in any way rubberised, do not have any kind of absorbance for ambient vibration (unlike a silicon or more permeable material) and that means that in the case of more enterprise/large-cap drives, the vibration will be amplified, rather than dissipated.

Again, this is not a deal breaker! But with so, so many NAS cases in the market that arrive with easy to inject/eject HDD trays, I always find it odd in 2024/2025 that companies like Phalcomm and Jonsbo still use these kinds of HDD accessories in their NAS systems.

When I installed smaller 4TB Seagate Ironwolf HDDs, they slide into each HDD cavity smoothly and without issue! However, when I installed a 24TB (10 platter) Seagate 24TB Ironwolf HDD – it did NOT go in smoothly and you definitely got the impression that injection and ejection of larger drives was going to be a little more friction filled.

Also, speaking of ejection, removing an HDD from the L8 enclosure was a less than elegant too. There is no ejection button, no handles for each drive bay and the only way to remove an active HDD (eg, in the event of an HDD failure in your RAID pool in order to introduce another one) was to grip the HDD by your finger tips and pull it out. It’s by no means the end of the world, but its pretty messy compared to if they had just equipped the system with HDD trays into each bay that were springloaded or just button ejection

I know it seems likes I am being very picky here – but the lack of smooth trays on the L8 really do hurt a lot of the impressively compact design choices on show here. Verticle HDD deployment has some great advantages in terms of space saving and redirecting active airflow throughout the system, but the way that drives are being injected into this system is not as smooth and seamless as the promotional images of the case would suggest on the websites that this case is being sold on.

As an ATX/MATX/MITX NAS case, there is ALOT to love here! But I do feel that Phalcomm dropped the ball in terms of the management of the HDDs and SSDs. They do a GREAT job in creating a more compact NAS case and, sort of a few tight spots around the physical cooling, they have achieved what they were going for here. But the SATA storage bays are not great and whether its a budget constraint or a design choice, this system needed trays BADLY!

Phalcomm / STUDEVOXL8 Case Review – Conclusion and Verdict

Overall, I WANT to like the Phalcomm NAS case… I really do. It’s a compact NAS case that has very, very broad Mobo, CPU, Cooler, PCIe and PSU support – THIS IS ALWAYS GOOD! However, they managed to drop the ball in how they approached the storage and I cannot see any good reason why they decided against dull but dependable tray deployment. The price point is fairly reasonable vs it’s competitors in 2024/2025… perhaps a pinch higher, but give it’s specifically compact design and scalability, I am prepared to give them a pass on the price tag. But, much like the (now old, old skool) Fractal Node 804, the approach towards the storage here in the L8 feels like a big step back vs other DiY NAS serves in the market. The Phalcomm L8 is a reasonable enough case, but one that I know will have BYO Server buyers occasionally scratching their heads. The L8 is NOT a bad case, but there are better cases out there.

DEAL WATCH Is It On Offer Right Now?

Silverstone CS382 NAS Case $209 Amazon usa USA $209 (16% off) [LINK]

These Offers are Checked Daily

 

PROS CONs
  • Compact Design: Despite supporting eight SATA drives and ITX/ATX motherboards, the case is surprisingly compact compared to other NAS enclosures.
  • Flexible Motherboard Support: Compatible with both ITX and ATX motherboards, offering flexibility for different build configurations.
  • Extensive Ventilation: Features passive ventilation on every side, ensuring good airflow and potential for keeping components cool.
  • Multiple Fan Mounting Options: The case has five optional fan mounting locations, allowing for customizable active cooling.
  • Spacious Interior: Provides plenty of room for motherboard and CPU cooler installation, supporting CPU coolers up to 158mm in height.
  • PCIe Expansion Support: Includes several PCIe expansion slots for additional components, allowing for future upgrades.
  • Easy Access for Installation: Removable storage cage and clear internal layout make motherboard and component installation straightforward.
  • Unique PSU Mounting: The PSU is mounted with copper risers to ensure proper airflow and space management, preventing overheating.
  • No Included Fans: Unlike some competitors, the Phalcomm L8 doesn’t come with any pre-installed fans, requiring additional purchases for active cooling.
  • Limited Front Features: The front panel lacks typical NAS features such as ejectable trays, LCD panels, or drive indicators.
  • Tight Fan Fit in the Front Cavity: Space is limited for front fans, which may lead to less-than-ideal installation, impacting airflow.
  • No Included Cables: The case does not come with SATA or power cables, which are essential for setting up the system.
📧 SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER 🔔
[contact-form-7]
🔒 Join Inner Circle

Get an alert every time something gets added to this specific article!


Want to follow specific category? 📧 Subscribe

This description contains links to Amazon. These links will take you to some of the products mentioned in today's content. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Visit the NASCompares Deal Finder to find the best place to buy this device in your region, based on Service, Support and Reputation - Just Search for your NAS Drive in the Box Below

Need Advice on Data Storage from an Expert?

Finally, for free advice about your setup, just leave a message in the comments below here at NASCompares.com and we will get back to you. Need Help? Where possible (and where appropriate) please provide as much information about your requirements, as then I can arrange the best answer and solution to your needs. Do not worry about your e-mail address being required, it will NOT be used in a mailing list and will NOT be used in any way other than to respond to your enquiry. [contact-form-7] TRY CHAT Terms and Conditions
If you like this service, please consider supporting us. We use affiliate links on the blog allowing NAScompares information and advice service to be free of charge to you.Anything you purchase on the day you click on our links will generate a small commission which isused to run the website. Here is a link for Amazon and B&H.You can also get me a ☕ Ko-fi or old school Paypal. Thanks!To find out more about how to support this advice service check HEREIf you need to fix or configure a NAS, check Fiver Have you thought about helping others with your knowledge? Find Instructions Here  
 
Or support us by using our affiliate links on Amazon UK and Amazon US
    
 
Alternatively, why not ask me on the ASK NASCompares forum, by clicking the button below. This is a community hub that serves as a place that I can answer your question, chew the fat, share new release information and even get corrections posted. I will always get around to answering ALL queries, but as a one-man operation, I cannot promise speed! So by sharing your query in the ASK NASCompares section below, you can get a better range of solutions and suggestions, alongside my own.

☕ WE LOVE COFFEE ☕

 
❌
❌